4.9
Over 205 Reviews
Expert Defence for Your Committal Hearing in Victoria
Facing a committal hearing in Victoria is a significant step in the criminal justice process. This stage is more than a formality; it determines whether your case proceeds to trial. It can involve cross-examining witnesses and testing the strength of the prosecution’s evidence. Below, we outline each step of the process and explain why early legal advice is crucial.
Understanding the Court Streams
If you’ve been charged, your case will fall into one of two court streams:
- Summary Stream: These matters are handled entirely in the Magistrates’ Court. They include offences like theft (under $100,000), driving offences, minor dishonesty matters, and some sexual offences.
- Committal Stream: More serious cases begin in the Magistrates’ Court but may proceed to the County or Supreme Court for trial. This includes serious charges such as rape, armed robbery, aggravated home invasion, murder, or complex fraud cases involving over $100,000.
The steps below outline the key stages for a matter proceeding through the committal stream.
Filing Hearing
This is the first administrative stage of your case. The court sets a strict timeline to ensure progress, so early legal advice is vital. At the filing hearing, the Court will set a timetable for:
- Hand-up Brief Deadline: This is the deadline by which police must provide a brief of evidence, including allegations, witness statements, and interview transcripts. Some material may be classified as restricted and only viewable by your legal team.
- Committal Mention Date: Set at this stage, this will be the first hearing date of your case
If you’re in custody, the filing hearing must occur within 7 days of charges being laid. If you’re on bail, it must happen within 28 days
Committal Mention
This is the first court appearance where the evidence is reviewed, but no witnesses are present. Your lawyer will file a document called a Form 32, outlining whether you intend to plead guilty or not guilty.
If pleading not guilty, your lawyer may apply to cross-examine witnesses at a contested committal hearing. This application must be specific: which witnesses, and why their cross-examination is necessary. This is a critical strategic decision and can significantly influence the strength of the case moving forward.
If pleading guilty, the matter may be resolved here or be transferred to a higher court, depending on the charge.
Preparation for the Committal Hearing
- Subpoena records or request further disclosure
- Consult expert witnesses
- Review restricted evidence at police or prosecution offices
- Investigate lines of defence or cross-examination strategy
Don’t be misled by any perceived delay between mention and hearing; your lawyers are working to build a strong case within a relatively short timeframe.
What Happens at the Committal Hearing
At the contested committal hearing, your lawyer can formally cross-examine witnesses and test the strength of the police evidence. This hearing isn’t just a formality; it’s often where key weaknesses in the prosecution’s case are revealed.
At the conclusion, the magistrate will decide whether there is sufficient evidence for a jury to reasonably convict. If so, you’ll be formally committed for trial, and the case will proceed to the County or Supreme Court.
What to Do Next
A committal hearing can be a powerful opportunity to challenge the evidence and shape the direction of your defence. But it must be handled with expertise, precision, and early preparation.
At Emma Turnbull Lawyers, our award-winning defence team are known for strong advocacy, clear advice, and unwavering client care. We provide strategic clarity at a time when the stakes are high.
Call (03) 9077 4834 or email admin@emmaturnbull.com.au to speak with an accredited criminal law specialist. Early advice can make all the difference.
FAQs
What is a committal hearing?
A committal hearing is a preliminary court proceeding in serious criminal matters. It allows the defence to challenge evidence and determine whether the case should proceed to trial in a higher court.
What is the difference between a committal mention and a committal hearing?
The committal mention is a procedural hearing where your plea is entered and cross-examination requests are submitted. The committal hearing is where evidence is tested, and witnesses may be cross-examined.
What is a committal mention in Victoria?
In Victoria, the committal mention occurs after the filing hearing. It is the point at which your legal team can indicate whether they will challenge witnesses and how the case is likely to proceed.
When will my case reach a committal hearing?
This varies depending on court timelines and case complexity. The committal hearing is scheduled after the committal mention and once all preparation steps have been completed.
What preparation is required before a committal hearing?
Preparation may include gathering evidence, requesting disclosure, reviewing expert reports, interviewing witnesses, and analysing the hand-up brief. Your lawyer will also make strategic decisions about whether to pursue cross-examination and how it fits into your broader defence.
What is the magistrate assessing at a committal hearing?
The magistrate must determine whether there is enough evidence that a jury could reasonably convict. This is known as the “prima facie” test.
What if I choose not to cross-examine witnesses?
In some cases, cross-examination isn’t necessary. Your lawyer will advise you whether it strengthens your case or risks revealing too much of your defence strategy.
Why engage a specialist lawyer early?
Early intervention allows your lawyer to manage tight court deadlines, request disclosure, apply for cross-examination, and begin building your defence strategy from day one.
Can I speak to you before any court date?
Yes. We strongly recommend contacting us as soon as you are charged or become aware of an investigation. Early advice can significantly affect your outcome.
